An empty seat in a 30-person company usually costs more than the owner thinks, even after the salary you stop paying. In the illustrative worked examples below, a vacant licensed tradesperson costs about $8,400 a month and a first-line supervisor about $4,800 a month. An office manager shows only about $600 a month in costs you can count, because most of what that vacancy costs is hard to put a number on. Those figures do not include the cost of filling the seat with the wrong person in a hurry. Hiring that is run for you costs $1,750 a month per position, with no placement fee and the option to cancel any month. The rest of this article shows the arithmetic so you can put in your own numbers. It also covers what a rushed hire adds to the bill and what the monthly fee pays for.
What goes into the cost of a vacant position?
Owners tend to think of an open seat as a saved salary. The salary is saved, but it is rarely the whole story. The cost falls into four places:
- Lost billable or production hours. These are jobs turned away, schedules pushed back, and output that never happens.
- Overtime and wear on the people covering. You pay time-and-a-half, and fatigue builds up in the people you most want to keep.
- The owner's own hours. This is time spent writing the ad, reading resumes, making phone screens, and holding interviews.
- The risk of a bad hire made under pressure. The longer a seat sits open, the lower the bar tends to drop.
The overtime cost goes beyond payroll. Dembe, Erickson, Delbos and Banks (2005) studied more than 10,000 U.S. workers. They found that jobs with overtime schedules carried a 61 percent higher injury hazard rate than jobs without overtime. In a shop or on a jobsite, covering an open seat with extra hours means more fatigue, more mistakes, and more risk.
Owner time is the cost that most often goes uncounted. A single posting can draw a stack of applicants, and most will not fit. Reading 100 resumes at three minutes each takes five hours. Add eight phone screens, three or four interviews, and the follow-up, and a search can take 15 to 20 hours of the owner's time. Those hours are not spent selling, estimating, or running the business. The examples below value an owner hour at $150. Use your own figure.
What does the arithmetic look like for three common roles?
The assumptions below are illustrative, not industry benchmarks. Replace them with your own rates and hours. Weekly figures are multiplied by 4.33 to get a monthly number. Each example subtracts the wages you are no longer paying, so the totals are net costs.
Licensed tradesperson
- Lost billings: 30 billable hours a week at $95 comes to $2,850. At a 40 percent gross margin, that is $1,140 a week in lost margin. The margin already accounts for the wages you are not paying on those hours.
- Overtime: other techs cover the remaining 10 hours at time-and-a-half on $38 an hour. You would have paid the absent tech $38 an hour for those hours anyway, so only the half-time premium is extra: $190 a week.
- Owner hours: 4 hours a week on the search at $150 is $600 a week.
The total is $1,930 a week, or about $8,400 a month. That figure counts only margin, not revenue, and it leaves out the customer who stops calling after you push their job back twice.
Office manager
- Overtime: staff cover 8 hours a week at time-and-a-half on $28 an hour, which is $336 a week.
- Owner hours: 6 hours a week doing the work plus running the search, at $150, is $900 a week.
- Pay you are not spending: an office manager paid about $57,000 a year costs about $1,100 a week, which comes off the total.
The countable total is $1,236 minus $1,100, or $136 a week, about $600 a month. That small number is the point of this example. Most of what this vacancy costs is left out of the arithmetic: late invoices, missed payables discounts, and billing errors, which are often the largest cost when the person who keeps the office running is gone.
First-line supervisor
- Production loss: a crew of eight produces about $25,000 of work a week. A 5 percent drop without day-to-day direction is $1,250 a week.
- Owner or operations manager covering: 8 hours a week at $150 is $1,200 a week.
- Pay you are not spending: a supervisor paid $70,000 a year costs about $1,346 a week, which comes off the total.
The total is $2,450 minus $1,346, or $1,104 a week, about $4,800 a month. That total leaves out rework, safety exposure, and crew members who start looking elsewhere because no one is leading them.
What does a hire made in a hurry add?
Turnover research gives a sense of what a bad hire costs. Boushey and Glynn (2012) reviewed 30 case studies and found a typical cost of about one-fifth of annual salary to replace a worker. The figure rose sharply for higher-paid and more specialized roles. Allen, Bryant and Vardaman (2010) note that the cost of replacing an employee can exceed a full year's salary for the position. Take a $70,000 supervisor who does not work out. Even Boushey and Glynn's typical one-fifth comes to about $14,000, and the seat then opens again. For more on what a wrong hire costs, see The Hidden Cost of Bad Hires.
How you choose matters as much as how fast you choose. In their review of decades of selection research, Schmidt and Hunter (1998) found that cognitive ability tests and structured interviews predict job performance better than unstructured interviews. Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens (2022) later re-estimated those figures with more careful corrections. Structured interviews came out at or near the top of the list. Unstructured interviews came out well below them. A friendly hour over coffee tends to measure how well a candidate presents. It does a poor job of predicting how they will lead a crew in March. For how to build one, see The Structured Interview.
From Practice
This composite draws on several client engagements. A specialty manufacturer with about 35 employees lost its second-shift supervisor in the busy season. The owner ran the shift himself for six weeks while also reading resumes at night. He then hired the candidate who interviewed best. Within a few months, two of the crew's most experienced operators had left, and scrap rates had climbed. The new supervisor was likeable, but he had no plan for getting work done through other people. Nobody had checked for that, because nobody had defined it.
The second search started from a written definition of the job's requirements. These included planning the shift, holding people accountable without drama, and solving problems on the floor. Every applicant was screened against those requirements. Finalists completed the ELLSIx Hiring Assessment and the Reasoning Assessment. The owner used structured interview questions tied to the same requirements. References were gathered through a structured survey and compared with the assessment results as one signal among several. The owner said the biggest difference was that he could explain why he was choosing one finalist over another.
How does $1,750 a month compare with the empty seat?
With TeamLMI's run-for-you hiring, the owner's role shrinks to the decisions that only the owner can make. TeamLMI writes the posting and attracts candidates on the major job boards and through direct outreach. It screens every applicant, and four of five never reach the owner's desk. Finalists are tested with ELLSIx (a forced-choice personality assessment built to resist faking), Reasoning, and Values, and an I-O psychologist reads the results. Each week the owner receives a report, and a client portal keeps every candidate in one place.
Compare the cost with the examples above. For the tradesperson and the supervisor, the $1,750 monthly fee is well below what the open seat was costing, about $8,400 and $4,800 a month. For the office manager, the countable cost of about $600 a month is below the fee. There, the case for help rests on the costs the arithmetic leaves out and on avoiding a rushed hire. There is no placement fee. A contingency recruiter typically charges a percentage of first-year salary, often in the 15 to 25 percent range, which is $10,500 to $17,500 on a $70,000 supervisor. With TeamLMI there is also no extra fee if more than one person is hired into the same position.
TeamLMI does not promise how long a search will take or how many candidates it will produce. No honest firm can. The monthly fee lets you judge the work month by month, and you can cancel any month. What you get is a structured process grounded in the selection research above, run by people who do it every day. Your hours go back into running the company.
If you have a seat open right now, the first step is a 20-minute fit call. Bring your numbers and the role you are trying to fill. Schedule a 20-minute fit call about run-for-you hiring to see whether it fits your company.
Sources
Research cited in this article, with links to the published work where available.
- Allen, D. G., Bryant, P. C., & Vardaman, J. M. (2010). Retaining talent: Replacing misconceptions with evidence-based strategies. Academy of Management Perspectives, 24(2), 48–64. https://doi.org/10.5465/amp.2010.51827775
- Boushey, H., & Glynn, S. J. (2012, November 16). There are significant business costs to replacing employees. Center for American Progress. https://www.americanprogress.org/article/there-are-significant-business-costs-to-replacing-employees/
- Dembe, A. E., Erickson, J. B., Delbos, R. G., & Banks, S. M. (2005). The impact of overtime and long work hours on occupational injuries and illnesses: New evidence from the United States. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 62(9), 588–597. https://doi.org/10.1136/oem.2004.016667
- Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., & Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection: Addressing systematic overcorrection for restriction of range. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040–2068. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000994
- Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1998). The validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology: Practical and theoretical implications of 85 years of research findings. Psychological Bulletin, 124(2), 262–274. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.124.2.262
